Best Pizza restaurant in Rochester
Fresh Pizza, Cold Drinks & Good Company
Order online the best pizza in Rochester!
Most-Loved Italian Classics
Discover the pizzas, sandwiches, and comfort food dishes our guests order again and again.
Chicken Parmesan
pasta in red sauce with a breaded chicken cutlet, topped with melted mozzarella
Add Item
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
White base, mozzarella, crispy chicken, tomatoes, celery, and blue cheese crumbles drizzled with buffalo sauce
Add Item
Cheeseburger Plate
Two all beef patties on a bed of mac salad and home fries covered in meat sauce and drizzled in mustard
Add Item
Order Your Favorites Online
Craving pizza, calzones, or Italian comfort food? Skip the wait and order online from Capone's at Murphy's Law. Enjoy quick pickup or convenient delivery throughout Rochester, including East Avenue, Downtown Rochester, Park Avenue, and surrounding neighborhoods. Fresh, delicious, and ready when you are.
Order NowProudly Serving the Heart of Rochester
Conveniently located on East Avenue, Capone's at Murphy's Law is surrounded by some of Rochester's most vibrant neighborhoods. Whether you're visiting Downtown Rochester, the Neighborhood of the Arts, or Park Avenue, we're the perfect stop for pizza, drinks, and Italian comfort food.
Visit UsWhat Our Customers Are Saying
From first-time visitors to loyal regulars, hear what makes Capone's a local favorite.
Jarrid Rockwood
Ordered a medium sausage pizza thin crust and crispy with bbq wings. It came out perfect. Pizza had just the right amount of sauce and cheese with no flop! The wings were big and cooked perfect and the blue cheese was even better. Happy to have found my new favorite pizza place in Rochester !
Nevaeh B
Had a great experience here! The food was fresh, flavorful, and came out quickly, i recommend the chicken wings!!! The staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. The restaurant was clean and had a great atmosphere. Everything we ordered was delicious, and the portions were ... generous. I would definitely come back and recommend this place to anyone looking for a great meal! Read More
C M
Capone's at Murphy's Law Thank you so much! The owner was super chill and nice. Without us asking he immediately gave us this Really good chicken cutlet on the house 🙏🏽 so Grateful. 🫶🏾🫶🏾 I love me a good chicken cutlet 😁 OH and the woman taking the orders was so so friendly and welcoming. All around Great vibes 👌🏽👌🏽
Adair Weaver
Have gotten food twice this week already, and have been very pleased both times. Tried the big milinase first and it was amazing!! Just had the buffalo pizza and also incredible! Can’t wait to try everything else they have.
James Simpson
The food was great and hit the spot. The staff were very friendly and fun. Would highly recommend!
Frequently Asked Questions
What dishes are you best known for?
We are best known for our Buffalo Chicken Calzone, The Antonia Pizza, Big Milanese Sub, Vegetariano Pizza, The Supremo Pizza, and more.
What type of cuisine do you serve?
What services do you offer?
What areas do you serve?
We are located in the heart of Rochester. We serve East Avenue, Neighborhood Of The Arts, Park Avenue, Downtown Rochester, and more surrounding areas.
Visit Capone's at Murphy's Law in Rochester
Join us on East Avenue for fresh pizza, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere.
Capone's at Murphy's Law
Business Hours
Sunday:
-
Monday:
-
Tuesday:
-
Wednesday:
-
Thursday:
-
Friday:
-
Saturday:
-
